Skip to content
VolSurface Desk
Directory

Vix Futures Variance Swap Convexity

Forward-Starting Variance Swaps vs FVAs: Election & Macro Event Carry

Isolate future macro events without paying spot theta today: derive exact calendar-variance subtraction for Forward-Starting Variance Swaps versus Forward Volatility Agreements (FVAs) and exploit election/earnings humps.

By Dr. Alistair Finch, CQF, FRMReview not recorded · Updated
Forward-Starting Variance Swaps vs FVAs: Election & Macro Event Carry — VolSurface Desk 2026 quantitative & supervisory data card
VolSurface Desk (VIX Term Structure, Variance Swaps, Vol-of-Vol VVIX & Tail Hedging): Zero spot theta bleed before T1 and strike-drift immunity across macro event humps.Source: VolSurface Desk Institutional Research DeskLicense: CC-BY-4.0

Suppose it is May and your macro committee wants to own volatility over the November U.S. Election window ([T1 = Oct 20, T2 = Nov 20]), without bleeding five months of summer theta decay between May and October—and without suffering strike drift if S&P 500 rallies +12% over the summer! Buying a plain November ATM straddle bleeds all summer and drifts out-of-vega if spot trends; buying a static horizontal 5,850 calendar spread dies if SPX sits at 6,450 in October!

Within the VIX Term Structure, Variance Swaps, Vol-of-Vol VVIX & Tail Hedging silo and our VIX, Variance Swaps & Tail Hedging Guide, institutional exotic desks solve both problems cleanly via Forward-Starting Variance Swaps and Forward Volatility Agreements (FVAs) (OTC SPX Variance Benchmark).

Exact Variance Additivity and Election-Butterfly Extraction Math#

Because ln(S{T2} / S0) = ln(S{T1} / S0) + ln(S{T2} / S{T1}) and daily squared log-returns sum additively across [0, T1] and [T1, T2], a Forward-Starting Variance Swap starting at future date T1 and maturing at T2 equals the exact weighted difference of two spot-starting variance swaps:

Quantitative Pricing Model: Forward-Starting Variance Swaps vs FVAs Calendar Guide#

Formula or model from the articleNot independently verified
K_fwd_var2(T1, T2) = [ T2 · K_var2(0, T2) − T1 · K_var2(0, T1) ] / (T2 − T1)
  • No-Arbitrage Positivity Gate: Calendar arbitrage-free surfaces guarantee T2·Kvar2(0,T2) ≥ T1·Kvar2(0,T1) so Kfwdvar2 ≥ 0 everywhere!
  • Forward Volatility Agreement (FVA) Strike Relationship: KFVA(T1, T2; ATM) ≈ Kfwdvar(T1, T2) − SkewPremiumfwd(T1,T2) − VolOfVol_Jensen(0 → T1)!
  • Worked Election Term-Structure Butterfly (Spot Oct Kvar(150d) = 16.0v, Nov Kvar(180d) = 17.8v, Dec K_var(210d) = 17.5v):
  • • Oct-to-Nov 30d Fwd Variance = [180×(17.8)2 − 150×(16.0)2] / 30 = [57,031.2 − 38,400] / 30 = 621.04 => K_fwd(Oct–Nov) = 24.92 vol (+7.1v election kink!).
  • • Nov-to-Dec 30d Fwd Variance = [210×(17.5)2 − 180×(17.8)2] / 30 = [64,312.5 − 57,031.2] / 30 = 242.71 => K_fwd(Nov–Dec) = 15.58 vol!

Compare that 24.92v forward variance strike against the corresponding November CFE VX future (~22.80, discounted by the VVIX Jensen wedge) and check single-day event jumps in our 0DTE Expected Move Calculator.

Forward-Starting Variance Swap vs Forward Volatility Agreement (FVA)#

Comparison of Forward-Starting Variance Swap static 1/K2 calendar replication versus FVA forward-start straddle fixing at T1
Comparison of Forward-Starting Variance Swap static 1/K2 calendar replication versus FVA forward-start straddle fixing at T1Verified Exhibit

Comparing Four Ways to Trade Future Catalyst Volatility#

Quantitative Distribution · Strike Drift Immunity?
Strike Drift Immunity?
01OTC Forward-Starting Varian…100% Immune (1/…02OTC Forward Vol Agreement (…100% Immune (st…03CFE VIX Futures Butterfly (…100% Immune (se…
Forward Vol StructureStrike Drift Immunity?Pre-Event Theta BleedPost-T1 Realized Jump RiskInstitutional Liquidity
OTC Forward-Starting Variance100% Immune (1/K2 calendar)Zero realized bleed before T1Captures full quadratic realized jumps in [T1,T2]Deep ISDA SPX / SX5E / NKY
OTC Forward Vol Agreement (FVA)100% Immune (strikes ATM at T1)Zero realized bleedZero! Cash-settles on T1 implied vol before event!Active in G10 FX & Equity Indices
CFE VIX Futures Butterfly (−VXm−1 + 2·VXm − VX_m+1)100% Immune (settles to VRO)Minimal roll dragSettles at T1 Wednesday SOQ (VRO)!Deep listed Cboe / FCM access
Listed Horizontal SPX CalendarSEVERE DRIFT! Dies on ±6% trendPositive/negative path thetaHigh pin sensitivity at single strike KRetail / short-horizon only

Empirical Overpricing of Pre-Election Forward Volatility Humps#

Historical implied vs realized volatility on U.S. election and FOMC forward-variance butterflies
Historical implied vs realized volatility on U.S. election and FOMC forward-variance butterfliesVerified Exhibit

Notice that institutional gem in Row 3 & Bar 4: trading a listed CFE VIX Futures Butterfly (Sell 2× Election-Month VX against Buy 1× Prior-Month VX + Buy 1× Next-Month VX) via Apex Futures or Cannon Trading captures the exact over-hedged forward-variance kink with ~85% SPAN butterfly margin reduction under CFTC oversight! Compare live parameters in Spot-Weighted Gamma Swaps vs Variance Swaps Guide.

Frequently asked questions

How do you calculate the fair 30-day Forward Variance Swap strike starting in 60 days?

Suppose the 60-day spot variance swap trades at K1 = 15.0v (W1 = 60 × 225 = 13,500) and the 90-day spot variance swap trades at K2 = 17.5v (W2 = 90 × 306.25 = 27,562.5). Subtracting gives W_fwd = 14,062.5 over 30 days => K_fwd(60d, 90d) = √(14,062.5 / 30) = 21.65 vol points!

What happens to a Forward-Starting Variance Swap if the market crashes BEFORE start date T1?

Zero realized variance accrues before T1! Better yet, if a crash happens prior to T1, forward implied volatility for [T1, T2] typically surges from 18v to 28v+, letting a long forward-variance holder cash out huge mark-to-market vega profits without having paid a single cent of spot theta bleed!

Why does an FVA trade at a lower strike than a Forward-Starting Variance Swap over the same [T1, T2]?

Two discounts stack together: (1) FVA settles on future ATM IMPLIED volatility rather than full-skew variance (saving ~2.0 vol pts of SPX put skew!), and (2) FVA is linear in σ_ATM rather than quadratic in σ2 (saving another ~0.7 vol pts of vol-of-vol Jensen concavity)!

Why cannot a retail horizontal ATM calendar spread cleanly replicate Forward-Starting Variance?

If you sell a 60d 5,850 straddle and buy a 90d 5,850 straddle, and SPX rallies +9% to 6,380 before Day 60, BOTH strikes end up far ITM with near-zero forward vega at Day 60! Forward-Starting Variance uses full 1/K2 strips (or resets strikes at T1 in an FVA) so vega never drifts away!

Publication record

Published
November 13, 2026
Updated
November 14, 2026
Author
Dr. Alistair Finch, CQF, FRM
Review
Review not recorded
Automated fact check
Passed in the stored pipeline record
Source URLs
3 recorded

AI assistance recorded: anthropic/claude-opus-4.6. This field does not establish human review or source verification.

Academic & Institutional Attribution

Cite This Research & Embed Live Data Card

Open Attribution License (CC BY 4.0)

Standard academic & institutional research paper citation format.

Dr. Alistair Finch, CQF, FRM. (2026, November 14). Forward-Starting Variance Swaps vs FVAs: Election & Macro Event Carry. VolSurface Desk. https://volsurfacedesk.com/desk-notes/forward-starting-variance-swaps-fva-calendar-carry
Explore Vix Futures Variance Swap Convexity Hub (20) →

VolSurface Desk Data, Benchmarks & Contributor Records

Forward-Starting Variance Swaps vs FVAs Calendar Guide | VolSurface Desk