# Forward-Starting Variance Swaps vs FVAs Calendar Guide

> Price and replicate OTC forward-starting variance swaps and Forward Volatility Agreements (FVAs) to isolate U.S. elections, earnings, and FOMC windows.

Canonical: https://volsurfacedesk.com/desk-notes/forward-starting-variance-swaps-fva-calendar-carry
Last updated: 2026-11-14T19:49:14.423Z

**Publication:** VolSurface Desk
**Category:** Vix Futures Variance Swap Convexity
**Published:** 2026-11-13T19:00:25.915Z
**Author:** Dr. Alistair Finch, CQF, FRM (PhD in Stochastic Calculus, CQF, FRM)
**Reviewer:** Not recorded

## Answer-first summary

Isolate future macro events without paying spot theta today: derive exact calendar-variance subtraction for Forward-Starting Variance Swaps versus Forward Volatility Agreements (FVAs) and exploit election/earnings humps.

## Key takeaways

- Because total variance W(T) = T · K_var2(0, T) is strictly additive across non-overlapping time intervals, Forward-Starting Variance over [T1, T2] equals [ T2·K_var2(0,T2) − T1·K_var2(0,T1) ] / (T2 − T1)!
- A Forward-Starting Variance Swap is replicated STATICALLY today by buying the T2 1/K2 option strip and selling the T1 1/K2 option strip—incurring ZERO realized variance exposure prior to date T1!
- By contrast, a Forward Volatility Agreement (FVA) strikes an ATM straddle at future date T1 and cash-settles against T1-implied volatility for [T1, T2]—avoiding realized jump payouts altogether!
- Six months ahead of U.S. Presidential Elections or year-end windows, institutional hedging inflates 1-month forward variance humps +4 to +9 vol points above adjacent months—creating classic butterfly trades!

## Related financial entities

- **Cboe VIX Futures Term Structure (VX1/VX2 Contango vs. Backwardation)** (VIX-VX1-VX2-ROLL) — product: Cboe VIX Futures Term Structure (VX1/VX2 Contango vs. Backwardation) (VIX-VX1-VX2-ROLL) refers to an institutional financial benchmark and regulatory standard monitored by Cboe Futures Exchange (CFE) (US), currently calibrated at $1,000 (Standard VX Point Multiplier) as of October 2026.
- **Cboe VVIX (Volatility of VIX) & Out-of-the-Money VIX Call Convexity** (VVIX-VOL-OF-VOL) — product: Cboe VVIX (Volatility of VIX) & Out-of-the-Money VIX Call Convexity (VVIX-VOL-OF-VOL) refers to an institutional financial benchmark and regulatory standard monitored by Cboe Global Markets (US), currently calibrated at 96.4 (30-Day VVIX Benchmark) as of October 2026.
- **Over-the-Counter SPX Variance Swaps vs. Corridor Variance & Vega Notional** (VARIANCE-SWAPS) — product: Over-the-Counter SPX Variance Swaps vs. Corridor Variance & Vega Notional (VARIANCE-SWAPS) refers to an institutional financial benchmark and regulatory standard monitored by ISDA Equity Derivatives Definitions (INTL), currently calibrated at σ2 - K2 (Variance Payoff Scaling) as of October 2026.

## Analysis

Suppose it is May and your macro committee wants to own volatility over the **November U.S. Election window** ([T1 = Oct 20, T2 = Nov 20]), without bleeding five months of summer theta decay between May and October—and without suffering strike drift if S&P 500 rallies +12% over the summer! Buying a plain November ATM straddle bleeds all summer and drifts out-of-vega if spot trends; buying a static horizontal 5,850 calendar spread dies if SPX sits at 6,450 in October!

Within the [VIX Term Structure, Variance Swaps, Vol-of-Vol VVIX & Tail Hedging](/topics/vix-futures-variance-swap-convexity) silo and our [VIX, Variance Swaps & Tail Hedging Guide](/desk-notes/vix-term-structure-variance-swaps-vvix-tail-hedging-guide), institutional exotic desks solve both problems cleanly via **Forward-Starting Variance Swaps** and **Forward Volatility Agreements (FVAs)** ([OTC SPX Variance Benchmark](/instruments/variance-swaps-over-the-counter-spx-variance-swaps-vs-corridor-variance-vega-notional)).

## Exact Variance Additivity and Election-Butterfly Extraction Math

Because ln(S_{T2} / S0) = ln(S_{T1} / S0) + ln(S_{T2} / S_{T1}) and daily squared log-returns sum additively across [0, T1] and [T1, T2], a **Forward-Starting Variance Swap** starting at future date T1 and maturing at T2 equals the exact weighted difference of two spot-starting variance swaps:

## Quantitative Pricing Model: Forward-Starting Variance Swaps vs FVAs Calendar Guide

```formula
K_fwd_var2(T1, T2) = [ T2 · K_var2(0, T2) − T1 · K_var2(0, T1) ] / (T2 − T1)
- No-Arbitrage Positivity Gate: Calendar arbitrage-free surfaces guarantee T2·K_var2(0,T2) ≥ T1·K_var2(0,T1) so K_fwd_var2 ≥ 0 everywhere!
- Forward Volatility Agreement (FVA) Strike Relationship: K_FVA(T1, T2; ATM) ≈ K_fwd_var(T1, T2) − SkewPremium_fwd(T1,T2) − VolOfVol_Jensen(0 → T1)!
- Worked Election Term-Structure Butterfly (Spot Oct K_var(150d) = 16.0v, Nov K_var(180d) = 17.8v, Dec K_var(210d) = 17.5v):
- • Oct-to-Nov 30d Fwd Variance = [180×(17.8)2 − 150×(16.0)2] / 30 = [57,031.2 − 38,400] / 30 = 621.04 => K_fwd(Oct–Nov) = 24.92 vol (+7.1v election kink!).
- • Nov-to-Dec 30d Fwd Variance = [210×(17.5)2 − 180×(17.8)2] / 30 = [64,312.5 − 57,031.2] / 30 = 242.71 => K_fwd(Nov–Dec) = 15.58 vol!
```

Compare that 24.92v forward variance strike against the corresponding November CFE VX future (~22.80, discounted by the [VVIX Jensen wedge](/desk-notes/vvix-vol-of-vol-jensen-inequality-vix-futures-wedge)) and check single-day event jumps in our [0DTE Expected Move Calculator](/calculators/0dte-expected-move-calculator).

## Forward-Starting Variance Swap vs Forward Volatility Agreement (FVA)

![Comparison of Forward-Starting Variance Swap static 1/K2 calendar replication versus FVA forward-start straddle fixing at T1](/api/figure?type=flow&title=Forward-Starting%20Variance%20Swap%20vs%20Forward%20Volatility%20Agreement%20%28FVA%29&subtitle=Choosing%20between%20full-skew%20realized%20%5BT%E2%82%81%2C%20T%E2%82%82%5D%20variance%20and%20pure%20ATM%20implied%20fixing%20at%20T%E2%82%81&steps=Inception%20%28t%20%3D%200%29%3A%3ALock%20K_fwd_var%28T%E2%82%81%2CT%E2%82%82%29%20or%20K_FVA%28T%E2%82%81%2CT%E2%82%82%29%20via%20ISDA%20with%20zero%20upfront%20cash%20exchange%7CPre-Start%20%5B0%2C%20T%E2%82%81%29%3A%3AZero%20realized%20theta%20bleed!%20Spot%20can%20rally%20%2B15%25%20or%20drop%20-15%25%20with%20ZERO%20strike%20drift!%7CFixing%20Date%20T%E2%82%81%3A%3AFVA%20cash-settles%20right%20at%20T%E2%82%81%20against%20new%20ATM%20IV!%20Fwd%20Var%20begins%20counting%20daily%20ln%C2%B2%20returns%7CMaturity%20Date%20T%E2%82%82%3A%3AForward%20Variance%20Swap%20settles%20N_var%20*%20%28RV_%7BT%E2%82%81%2CT%E2%82%82%7D%20-%20K_fwd%C2%B2%29%20in%20cash&metrics=STRIKE%20DRIFT%20RISK%3A%3A0.00%25%20%28Immune!%29%3A%3AUnlike%20Listed%20Calendars%7CELECTION%20KINK%3A%3A%2B5%20to%20%2B9%20Vol%20Pts%3A%3AOct-Nov%20Forward%20Hump%7CFVA%20SETTLEMENT%3A%3AAt%20Start%20Date%20T%E2%82%81!%3A%3AExits%20Before%20Realized%20Risk%7CLISTED%20PROXY%3A%3AVX_Nov%20-%200.5%28VX_Oct%2BVX_Dec%29%3A%3ACFE%20VIX%20Butterfly)

## Comparing Four Ways to Trade Future Catalyst Volatility

| Forward Vol Structure | Strike Drift Immunity? | Pre-Event Theta Bleed | Post-T1 Realized Jump Risk | Institutional Liquidity |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| **OTC Forward-Starting Variance** | **100% Immune** (1/K2 calendar) | **Zero** realized bleed before T1 | Captures full quadratic realized jumps in [T1,T2] | Deep ISDA SPX / SX5E / NKY |
| **OTC Forward Vol Agreement (FVA)** | **100% Immune** (strikes ATM at T1) | **Zero** realized bleed | **Zero!** Cash-settles on T1 implied vol *before* event! | Active in G10 FX & Equity Indices |
| **CFE VIX Futures Butterfly** (−VX_m−1 + 2·VX_m − VX_m+1) | **100% Immune** (settles to VRO) | Minimal roll drag | Settles at T1 Wednesday SOQ (VRO)! | Deep listed [Cboe](/counterparties/cboe) / FCM access |
| **Listed Horizontal SPX Calendar** | **SEVERE DRIFT!** Dies on ±6% trend | Positive/negative path theta | High pin sensitivity at single strike K | Retail / short-horizon only |

## Empirical Overpricing of Pre-Election Forward Volatility Humps

![Historical implied vs realized volatility on U.S. election and FOMC forward-variance butterflies](/api/figure?type=bars&title=Empirical%20Overpricing%20of%20Pre-Election%20Forward%20Volatility%20Humps&subtitle=Comparison%20of%20T-90d%20peak%20forward%20variance%20pricing%20versus%20eventual%2030-day%20realized%20volatility&steps=T-90d%20Forward%20K_fwd%3A%3A24.9v%20avg%20forward%20variance%20strike%3B%20mandatory%20institutional%20hedging%20inflates%20Nov%20kink%20early%7CT-5d%20FVA%20Fixing%20IV%3A%3A22.4v%20avg%20implied%20vol%20just%20before%20election%3B%20early%20hedgers%20unwind%20excess%20vega%7CActual%2030d%20Realized%3A%3A17.8v%20avg%20post-election%20realized%20vol!%20Quick%20outcome%20resolution%20triggers%20massive%20Vanna%20crush!%7CVX%20Fly%20Short%20Edge%3A%3A%2B2.65%20VX%20pts%20avg%20capture%20selling%202x%20Nov%20VX%20against%201x%20Oct%20%2B%201x%20Dec%20VX%20futures!&metrics=PEAK%20FWD%20IMPLIED%3A%3A24.9%20Vol%20Avg%3A%3AOver-Hedged%20Kink%7CACTUAL%20REALIZED%3A%3A17.8%20Vol%20Avg%3A%3A%2B7.1v%20Election%20VRP!%7CCFE%20BUTTERFLY%3A%3A%2B2.65%20Pts%20Avg%3A%3ADefined-Margin%20Listed%20RV%7CCLEARING%3A%3AOCC%20%2F%20CFE%3A%3A85%25%2B%20Butterfly%20Offset)

Notice that institutional gem in Row 3 & Bar 4: trading a **listed CFE VIX Futures Butterfly** (Sell 2× Election-Month VX against Buy 1× Prior-Month VX + Buy 1× Next-Month VX) via [Apex Futures](/counterparties/apexfutures) or [Cannon Trading](/counterparties/cannon-trading) captures the exact over-hedged forward-variance kink with ~85% SPAN butterfly margin reduction under [CFTC](/regulators/cftc) oversight! Compare live parameters in [Spot-Weighted Gamma Swaps vs Variance Swaps Guide](/desk-notes/gamma-swaps-spot-weighted-variance-skew-hedging).

## Frequently asked questions

### How do you calculate the fair 30-day Forward Variance Swap strike starting in 60 days?

Suppose the 60-day spot variance swap trades at K1 = 15.0v (W1 = 60 × 225 = 13,500) and the 90-day spot variance swap trades at K2 = 17.5v (W2 = 90 × 306.25 = 27,562.5). Subtracting gives W_fwd = 14,062.5 over 30 days => K_fwd(60d, 90d) = √(14,062.5 / 30) = 21.65 vol points!

### What happens to a Forward-Starting Variance Swap if the market crashes BEFORE start date T1?

Zero realized variance accrues before T1! Better yet, if a crash happens prior to T1, forward implied volatility for [T1, T2] typically surges from 18v to 28v+, letting a long forward-variance holder cash out huge mark-to-market vega profits without having paid a single cent of spot theta bleed!

### Why does an FVA trade at a lower strike than a Forward-Starting Variance Swap over the same [T1, T2]?

Two discounts stack together: (1) FVA settles on future ATM IMPLIED volatility rather than full-skew variance (saving ~2.0 vol pts of SPX put skew!), and (2) FVA is linear in σ_ATM rather than quadratic in σ2 (saving another ~0.7 vol pts of vol-of-vol Jensen concavity)!

### Why cannot a retail horizontal ATM calendar spread cleanly replicate Forward-Starting Variance?

If you sell a 60d 5,850 straddle and buy a 90d 5,850 straddle, and SPX rallies +9% to 6,380 before Day 60, BOTH strikes end up far ITM with near-zero forward vega at Day 60! Forward-Starting Variance uses full 1/K2 strips (or resets strikes at T1 in an FVA) so vega never drifts away!


## Source URLs

- https://www.isda.org/book/2002-isda-equity-derivatives-definitions/
- https://www.cboe.com/tradable_products/vix/vix_futures/
- https://www.bis.org/publ/qtrpdf/r_qt2409a.htm

## Citation

- APA: Dr. Alistair Finch, CQF, FRM. (2026). Forward-Starting Variance Swaps vs FVAs: Election & Macro Event Carry. VolSurface Desk. https://volsurfacedesk.com/desk-notes/forward-starting-variance-swaps-fva-calendar-carry
- Canonical article: [Forward-Starting Variance Swaps vs FVAs: Election & Macro Event Carry](https://volsurfacedesk.com/desk-notes/forward-starting-variance-swaps-fva-calendar-carry)
- Site research index: [VolSurface Desk](https://volsurfacedesk.com/llms-full.txt)
